Short Answer
The response encouraged focusing first on what the biblical text clearly teaches rather than emphasizing theological labels. Romans 3 plainly teaches humanity’s universal sinfulness and inability to achieve righteousness before God. While Calvinists and Arminians may explain some implications differently, both should agree that salvation is entirely dependent on God’s grace.
If you’re serving in a church with different theological emphases, teach the passage faithfully, honor your pastor’s leadership, avoid unnecessary division, and major on the gospel rather than theological camps.
The Overview
This discussion addressed a teacher serving in a Calvary Chapel church who had become more Reformed in his understanding of salvation but wanted to teach Romans fairly without causing unnecessary conflict.
Start with the Text
Rather than beginning with Calvinism or Arminianism, the recommendation was to begin with Scripture itself.
Romans 3 repeatedly emphasizes:
- no one is righteous
- no one seeks God
- all have turned aside
- everyone stands guilty before God
These truths should remain the central focus regardless of one’s theological system.
Humanity’s Sin Problem
The discussion stressed that Scripture presents sin as a profound condition affecting every person.
Supporting passages mentioned include:
- Romans 3
- Ephesians 2
- Jeremiah 17
- Ezekiel 36
- Isaiah 59
- Romans 5
Together, these passages describe humanity as spiritually helpless apart from God’s gracious intervention.
Areas of Agreement
Rather than highlighting disagreements first, the speaker encouraged emphasizing what thoughtful Christians commonly affirm:
- All people are sinners
- No one can save themselves
- Salvation depends entirely upon God’s grace
- People must respond to the gospel
- God deserves all the glory for salvation
Building upon these shared convictions promotes unity while faithfully teaching Scripture.
Avoid Making Labels the Main Point
The advice was not to structure lessons around:
- Calvinism
- Arminianism
- Total Depravity
- Five Points
Instead, simply explain what the passage says.
Theological systems can help organise doctrine, but they should not overshadow the biblical text itself.
Serving Faithfully Within Your Church
The caller explained that he had spoken honestly with his pastor about his theological convictions while remaining committed to serving without creating division.
The response affirmed this attitude.
Christians should:
- submit to godly church leadership
- serve humbly
- Avoid unnecessary controversy
- Continue teaching Christ faithfully
Unless convictions eventually require a different church home, believers should pursue peace and unity while remaining faithful to Scripture.
Keep the Gospel Central
The discussion concluded by reminding teachers that regardless of theological nuances, every Christian should proclaim the same gospel:
People are sinners.
Christ alone saves.
God graciously opens blind eyes.
Believers respond in repentance and faith.
All glory belongs to God.
Key Takeaways
- Teach the Text First
Let Romans 3 speak for itself. - Everyone Has a Sin Problem
Humanity stands guilty before God. - Salvation Is by Grace
No one saves themselves. - Avoid Unnecessary Labels
Focus on biblical truth over theological camps. - Pursue Unity
Serve faithfully without causing division. - Keep Christ Central
The gospel should remain the primary message.
Bible Verses Mentioned
- Romans 3:10–18
- Romans 5
- Romans 10
- Ephesians 2
- Jeremiah 17:9
- Ezekiel 36
- Isaiah 59:2
- Jude 23
- 1 Corinthians 1:10
Read Full Raw Transcript
Matthew, you’re on the air with Mike. How can I help? I thought so, Mike, let me just give you some context here. So I kind of grew up in the Calvary Chapel Church and eventually went to your church for a few years before I had to move.
It wasn’t until I listened to your sermons on Romans eight and nine, where I became more reformed and with my soteriology. Fast forwarding now a few years I’ve been teaching my local churches, junior high group and like a Sunday school environment. And we’re going through Romans and it’s Calvary Chapel and they’re not necessarily, you know, five point Calvinists over there, as you can tell.
But I did align with my pastor that like, I’ll try to give a fair view of both sides of the different passages that come up Arminian and Calvinist. And he’s totally aligned and it thinks it’s fair. I use the MacArthur New Testament commentary and stuff like that. But I’m just wondering on your end, what’s a fair representation of Romans chapter three, verses ten and beyond?
Like who do they think that person is if it’s not everyone that can’t believe? Just to fairly represent their side? Well, I think if you’re going to look at that list, if you’re listening, you don’t remember what Romans 310 is. That’s where it starts quoting all the Old Testament passages about our sin and stating passages that will say it in the most superlative way.
None is righteous. No not one. No one understands. No one seeks for God. They’ve all turned aside. Together. They become worthless. No one does good, not even one. And then it goes on even further with a lot more Old Testament references, many of them from the Psalms and Proverbs. But the idea of saying, well, what would an Armenian do?
It really is more of the question. If you go back to Pelagius, Palladian and Augustine in their debate, I mean that that kind of which I guess I mean, depending on your level of understanding, Matthew, the, the idea of of what you would call Arminian today versus Calvinism, a lot of the Armenian ism is a kind of it grows out of an understanding of, of Pelagius view of the fact that we’re born innocent.
Right? And then sin is corrupting our lives as we choose to sin, as opposed to the idea of the fact that we’re we’re all born in sin, conceived in sin, that we are dead in our trespasses and sins like the rest of mankind. To quote Ephesians two, and I know you know those passages. But when you look at a passage like this and you say well known as righteous, I guess you would say, if we’re not talking about the whole of humanity, and we’re not talking about humanity from conception forward, because they’re all daughters and and sons of, of Adam and Eve, then they’re going to say with a kind of plaguing or semi Pelagius
view. Well, they’re, they’re not, they’re not unrighteous until they become unrighteous. Right. They’re, they’re not this bad until, you know, they prove to be this bad. But it’s the general arc of, of the, of the behavior of human beings. Right. And so of course, I’m having a hard time disappointing that. But because it seems like from all of the Bible I just referenced quickly Jeremiah’s, you know, simple statement that the human heart is, is desperately wicked.
It doesn’t understand, it can’t. And you know, or even Ezekiel 36, our hearts are stone and they need to be made into hearts of flesh. So it’s hard for me to say other than to say I think people would say, well, we’re not all bad. That’s the kind of view. It’s not all of us, but we are. We were all we all interact with sin.
We’re all sinners, but we’re not, you know, so bad that we, you know, we don’t at some point get awakened by and even that I’m trying to and here’s the point. And I’ll get to what I’m about to say in a second about commonality. There is a commonality that even people would say, when I say no one would seek after God until they’re awakened to it somehow by the preaching of the gospel.
Well, I think the one side is going to say, well, that’s not even going to happen unless God’s Spirit is involved, which even I’ll hear Arminians say that clearly. And they’re going to say at some point they’ll understand. The Pelagius view would be, well, they understand because they can inherently understand. And Augustine would say, no, they can’t understand because they’re dead in their sins and they they don’t get it.
Well, those have grown into much more obvious systems than Arminianism and Calvinism. And I just think if I’m teaching a junior high group and don’t think it’s hard, even among junior hires, to preach a passage like Romans three and said, and to say what Ephesians two says, don’t we all see that this is the truth of our lives?
We are bent, is sin, and we didn’t have to be taught to sin. And because God is a perfect, holy God and there’s none righteous except for God, as Jesus made clear when they called him a good teacher, and he said, no one’s good but God alone. We all know we’re in the category of sin and even even junior hires.
I would hope if they’re under the teaching of God’s Word can come to the place of admitting that and seeing that. And certainly their parents, I hope, would be able to see it. But I just all of it gets muted in some way. If you’re trying to find some Palladian place of saying maybe there’s enough innocence in us that we can decide to follow God without God’s intervention.
But I’ve even heard of late some people that don’t even they would they would nowhere near call themselves Calvinistic. That will say the same thing. And that is. Yeah, without God’s help, without God’s Spirit, they would say, well, you know, we’re not ever going to be seeking after God, right? And so these are superlative phrases and it’s hard to get around them.
I’m trying my best to say how maybe someone would, but they would say, yeah, the seeking of God is maybe something that comes alive in someone when the climate is right and the words are right, and faith comes by hearing and hearing by the word. To quote Romans ten. And so there’s still triggers. What we’re going to say at the end of the day is that I hope even some Arminians and Calvinists can say together is that none of this happens without without God being credited with it all.
And that’s the point. The glory of God alone. This is God who is saving sinners, who don’t seek after him, but he by his grace draws them, and they seek after God. Now that leaves them with a dilemma that they don’t want. And I get that, and that is, well, why doesn’t need to do this to everyone? And and I get that.
But that’s where I would probably if I’m under a church that isn’t going to share all your views and all the implications of your views, I would teach what you can teach without getting, you know, in trouble with your pastor until your convictions get too far and you pick another church. But I would say with junior hires especially, I could probably preach for, you know, hours and hours and hours without ever running into a conflict that’s going to get the pastors upset with what I’m teaching, because I’m teaching things that I think everyone should readily be able to understand.
We are sinners and we need the grace of God to respond. And I would say I’m calling them to a response. And this is where some people think, if you don’t have the view I have, you’re never going to call someone to a decision. I had a long letter on my desk recently of someone very mad at me because I used the word decision.
I have no problem with using the terms that we see throughout Scripture, from Moses saying to choose life all the way into the New Testament times, where Jesus is confronting people with a with a proposition and expecting them to decide rightly. And I think that’s fine, as long as at the end of the day, we can all say we give glory to God for opening our eyes and making blind eyes see and deaf ears hearing.
So that was probably unsatisfying, Matthew, to to talk through Romans chapter three. But everyone’s been affected by sin, I think enough in their experience to look at that passage and say, yeah, even if I don’t agree, it’s as bad as it seems to sound. I do know there’s some bad that’s affected us all. But of course, I think the more we read scripture, the more we say, wow, that bad is affected us so deeply, so profoundly that it’s not an overstatement to say what it says, just straight right forward.
No one seeks to God. No one understands because in ourselves we don’t. Matter of fact, you can’t live, I can’t live, and this is where I think if we start looking outside of theology just into biology, God says in him we live and move and have our being. I can’t survive, I can’t do anything today if God doesn’t animate me right in him.
All things hold together. All things are from him and through him and to him. And I just think all of us should know everything is contingent ultimately on God. And I wouldn’t be who I am, even for another second, to be able to think about what I would have for lunch today, where God to to remove his animating spirit from the interaction with my spirit.
It’s impossible. So what I like to do with this debate, and I hear it all the time, and of course, even on this, you know, set of questions that have come in, I see people asking this issue. I don’t want us to try and build walls between us. I want us to keep looking at Scripture and build bridges together to say, let’s let’s come together with what we can agree.
And I hope in Romans chapter three, most people and their parents that you’re teaching can say, yeah, we agree we have a sin problem. It’s severe. And if we’re left to our own devices, yeah, everything in this passage would would be a reality in my resume. I mean, I would have feet that are swift to shed blood and my path would be ruin in misery.
And as often is said about the doctrine of sin, we’re not as bad as we could be, right by God’s common grace. Right? But we’re certainly as bad off as we possibly could be, right? We’re not. We couldn’t be any worse than we are being alienated from God. As Isaiah 59 two says, right, we are sins of separation between us and God.
And that sin didn’t begin when I was 7 or 17. According to Romans five, it began because I was conceived as a child of Adam, and immediately I’m already on the bus heading down the cliff. As I’ve said in my teaching in Romans that you’ve heard we’re already on the bus that’s already heading off the cliff. We need God to pluck us out of this.
Or, as Jude put it, to, to pluck us from the fire. Right. Snatches from the fire. So, yeah, teach sin I wouldn’t even try to make if I were you, Matthew. And I’m not trying to upset your old teaching method. I wouldn’t even try to present passage and say, here’s one way to look at it. Here’s another way.
I would just go for what it says and avoid the labels in the topics and the banners and just say, let’s look at this text, which I think I’ve modeled in my teaching of Romans. I’m not here to try and and make big category distinctions with labels on them, which occasionally I had to, I suppose, with Agustina and some concepts related to Calvinism and Arminianism.
But still, I think we can preach all day long with great agreement about the problem of sin. It’s just those extreme examples that sometimes people are going to say, but you can’t believe that. You can’t believe that. And of course, I think it becomes theoretical and not practical, because most of us can agree that sin is a problem.
And if it weren’t for God, we would stay in our on our mess of sin. And the real test is that last distinctive, which is does someone take credit for their salvation, their own salvation? And if they do, then I think, okay, we can go back to square one and say, then we don’t understand what it is for the one who can save, to save those who are helpless to save themselves.
And I guess that’s a different way to say things you can say in a much more pejorative way about total depravity or whatever. But we’re helpless to save ourselves, and in most of my Armenian friends will clearly say that. And I think we put our arm around each other and say, yes, that’s the problem. And so we seek the Lord, we seek his favor, and we ask for him to utilize us in our evangelism to get us to understand and get us to seek him and get us to come to a place of being his child.
Does any of that help? Matthew, that was really good. Yeah, I appreciate it. I would say like a year ago, I was kind of struggling with kind of being, I’m just going to make a little funny term, like a closet Calvinist at my church. And I didn’t know what a what I should do, but I kind of just like talked to the pastor one on one and kind of, you know, shared that, like, I see things a lot differently than a lot of the other folks at my church.
You know, even you were talking about gifts a second ago, but I haven’t had the conviction where, like, I feel like I need to move the church, like go to a different church. I should still be part of this place. Good, but still submit to his authority and cause any division. So I like that. It was a good talk, but yeah, I like that a lot.
That seems like a good attitude. And you know, I don’t want I mean, I want First Corinthians one tend to be true in every church that we can be united in mind and thought. And so we do the best we can, even in the nuanced distinctions we may have. And they are somewhat nuanced, because, again, I think we can agree even on the sociological issues, on the major issues.
It’s just when we start talking theoretical, people start to see the gap. But be gracious, be kind, and and just keep teaching those junior hires. They need Christ. And of course, as Paul likes to talk about, even, we look at the time frame of our own experience right on this side of the tapestry. It’s all all the same, right?
We get hit with conviction. Sermons. We don’t even maybe not even understand the Spirit’s work. But the spirit is working through those sermons or through that evangelism, through that encounter with someone who’s telling me about Christ. And we fall under a conviction and we cry out to God and we say, I’m a sinner and have mercy on me, and we go home justified.
And we may not even understand the depth of theology in all of that, but we can certainly do that. We can we can say that we can teach that. We can call people to that, and we can pray for God to be graciously using us, whether it’s in junior high life or senior citizens lives. But keep up the good work.
The Bible Can Inform Our Everyday Decisions...
Get Biblical clarity on complex questions that can weigh on your heart and mind. "Biblical Answers to 12 Challenging Questions" is a free resource specially designed for Christians looking to the Bible to direct their lives. This guide provides insightful answers to pressing questions that you may have. Taken from interviews with Pastor Mike Fabarez, this resource addresses thought-provoking topics such as:
- Is it Okay for Christians to Get Cremated?
- Do I Need to be Baptized to be Saved?
- Do Good People Go to Hell?
- Are Tattoos Biblical?
- And more!
To receive your FREE 65-page copy of Biblical Answers to 12 Challenging Questions by Pastor Mike Fabarez, please fill in your information in the form below to receive a download link.
Contact Permission
By clicking the "Download" button above, I am requesting to receive e-mail communications from Focal Point Ministries, and I agree to allow my personal data to be processed according to their Internet Privacy Policy.
By optionally entering my mobile number above, I also agree to receive automated text messages from Focal Point Ministries.